Shipowners

Are you planning a new ferry build?

Focusing on total cost of ownership brings substantial savings to ferry owners

Narjiss Ghajour Send an email May 11, 2022
1,744 4 minutes read
Ferry

 

Are you planning a new ferry build? If the answer is yes, then you would probably want to optimise your costs by focusing on the Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) instead of kW-power.  Choosing the propulsion unit based mainly on Capex, for example, will most likely increase costs in the long run. In this article we present a case study, showing that a ferry owner can save more than two million euros over a 15-year period by concentrating on the TCO.

The traditional way of handling the procurement of propulsion systems, among other things, is to request quotations for propulsion units based on one specific value, typically kW-power. The one with the lowest price 53often wins the bid, contributing to lowering the newbuilding unit cost.

However, we need to consider that the cost of a newly built ferry makes up only a fraction of the TCO. A ferry, as well as any other vessel, is designed to be in service for many years. Therefore, it is important to consider the vessel’s purpose and planned operation when choosing the propulsion solution.

Comparing different propulsion system suppliers can be a complicated process when a holistic picture of a ferry’s lifecycle costs is unavailable. For a ferry doing daily repetitive crossings the TCO is what matters the most. The total cost of ownership includes the newbuilding unit cost, maintenance and spare part costs as well as operational energy costs. The current procurement process focusses only on the newbuilding unit cost, even though the energy costs are by far the dominating factor when we talk about TCO.

Simulation-based ferry propulsion design for a 120 CEU double-ended ferry

At Steerprop we decided to examine the TCO impact by doing a simulated case study of some very likely operating scenarios.

We wanted to find out the best ways to design a ferry propulsion system. The example used in the study was a 120 CEU (Car Equivalent Unit) double-ended ferry that would run on four ferry routes of different lengths and crossing times.

Ferry

Selecting the variables

In addition to the given vessel characteristics, several other variables also need to be decided. These cover project information, propulsor variables and operational variables for the crossing. Among others, these parameters were used:

  • Project information. This area covered features such as route length, target crossing time, bollard pull requirement (optional), which are details usually defined by the owner. Ship specific data is then provided by the ship designer, including displacement, resistance curve, thrust deduction and wake fraction.
  • Propulsor variables. The following parameters were used for the propulsor: propeller diameter, RPM and pitch design point, and propulsion max power. Secondary variables were auxiliary systems power and lubrication oil temperature.
  • Crossing operational variables. When simulating the crossing, these variables were used: manoeuvring time and length at both ends, acceleration time and power, crossing speed (knots), deceleration time, including angle and power of the propulsors. Moreover, the power was split between front and aft units in all modes.

Steerprop was looking for the total energy used for the different crossings (kWh) in the study. This was complemented by combining a specific cost model where attention was given to the energy cost for the crossing (€) and the cost of the propulsion unit (including initial and maintenance costs). For the total cost of ownership, a 15-year period was selected. We also added the possibility to compare different propulsion configurations.

Designing the optimal propulsion unit 

How to design the optimal propulsion unit? The answer lies in the balance between Capex (Capital Expenditures) and Opex (Operating Expenses) on the one hand, and the relation between power and torque on the other. For example, a propulsion unit that has better acceleration capabilities or a free running efficiency might cost slightly more but reduces energy consumption significantly. The challenge is to find the best optimal balance. With low power, we gain low Opex, whereas with low torque, we gain low Capex.226

It is possible to find the optimal combination of Capex and Opex through studies using both route simulation and cost models.

Operational analysis forms the basis for an optimal TCO

The actual simulation was performed using four ferry routes and three CRP (contra-rotating propellers) propulsion options. The ferry routes, including distances and crossing times used, are shown in Table 1.

Ferry

The three CRP propulsion alternatives studied are based on one baseline, which is a “standard” solution fulfilling the minimum requirements. The two other options focus on increased efficiency and optimised acceleration, respectively. These two options incur some extra capital expenditures, but the results show that they also have a very short payback time thanks to significantly lower operating costs. Options two and three contain different variables compared to option one.

Table 2 above shows that options one and two use a reduced RPM for the propeller and increased torque and an enlarged propeller diameter, among other things. These two options also have a higher Capex, but the results show that there are also substantial annual savings that improve the total cost of ownership.

The results outlined in Figure 2 clearly show that from a TCO perspective, it pays to design propulsion units according to the vessel’s operational profile.

Option two consumes 13% less energy than the “baseline” option on the 14 minute-crossing. We can also see clear annual savings for both options on all ferry routes, which vouches for short payback times, especially on the shorter crossings.

The second option, which focuses on optimising the acceleration phases, benefits ferries operating short crossings where accelerations occur frequently. The total cost of ownership in the 4 km crossing example is slightly over 17,000,000 euros. If we look at annual savings exceeding 160,000 euros, we can see that over a 15-year period, the total savings are more than 2.4 million euros.

The simulation results show that operational analysis is the foundation for finding an optimal total cost of ownership. In addition, significant energy savings can be achieved by involving propulsor design as part of the ship design process.

This article is shared by courtesy of Steerprop, a leading designer and manufacturer of azimuth propulsion systems for the most demanding applications and toughest conditions. www.steerprop.com

For more news about ferries, click here.

 

Tags
Narjiss Ghajour Send an email May 11, 2022
1,744 4 minutes read
Photo of Narjiss Ghajour

Narjiss Ghajour

Editor-in-Chief of Maritime Professionals

9,256 Comments

  203. Mesothelioma is a cancer of the lung’s lining (pleura) and stomach (peritoneal mesothelioma) and heart.

    The symptoms usually develop over time. If a patient’s doctor suspects mesothelioma they could take
    a biopsy to confirm the diagnosis.

    my homepage :: Asbestos Lawyer

  427. I not to mention my guys have been reading through the best tricks located on the website and then got an awful suspicion I had not thanked you for them. My young boys are already as a result thrilled to study all of them and already have seriously been making the most of these things. Many thanks for being very thoughtful and for using this sort of ideal things most people are really desirous to discover. My sincere regret for not saying thanks to you earlier.

    my blog – Singapore Condo Floor Plans (http://www.nuursciencepedia.com/index.php/Benutzer:LeonoreBrereton)

  483. Mesothelioma lawyers who have experience are aware of the laws of the state pertaining to mesothelioma lawsuits.
    They will determine the best location to file an asbestos lawsuit.
    They can help in identifying potential sources of Asbestos Legal exposure.

  973. I delight in, result in I discovered just what I used to be taking a look for. You have ended my four day long hunt! God Bless you man. Have a nice day. Bye

  1204. How To Get Diagnosed With ADHD UK Tips To Relax Your Everyday Lifethe Only How
    To Get Diagnosed With ADHD UK Trick That Every Person Must Learn how to get
    diagnosed with adhd uk (Orval)

  1248. Tall 50 50 Fridge Freezer Tips To Relax Your Everyday Lifethe Only Tall 50 50 Fridge Freezer Technique Every Person Needs To Know 50 50 fridge freezer, Rick,

  1265. I think this is among the most significant information for me.
    And i am satisfied studying your article. But wanna commentary on some general
    things, The web site style is great, the articles is really excellent : D.

    Just right activity, cheers

  1307. Drip Irrigation Pipes in Iraq At Elite Pipe Factory, our drip irrigation pipes are engineered to provide efficient water delivery for agricultural applications. These pipes are designed to minimize water wastage and enhance crop yields, reflecting our commitment to advancing irrigation technology in Iraq. As a leading and reliable manufacturer, Elite Pipe Factory ensures that our drip irrigation pipes are of the highest quality, contributing to successful farming practices. Explore our drip irrigation solutions at elitepipeiraq.com.

  1313. Spot on with this write-up, I actually think this amazing site needs a great
    deal more attention. I’ll probably be returning to read
    through more, thanks for the information!

  1341. Asbestos Attorneys Georgia Tools To Help You Manage Your Daily Lifethe One Asbestos Attorneys Georgia Trick That Everybody Should Be Able To asbestos
    attorneys; Elwood,

  1342. Are You Sick Of Love Doll Realistic? 10 Inspirational
    Ideas To Revive Your Love For Love Doll Realistic world
    most realistic sex doll – Enid –

  1421. You’ll Never Be Able To Figure Out This Lightweight 3 Wheel Stroller’s Tricks lightweight
    3 wheel stroller, https://vikingwebtest.Berry.edu/ICS/Berry_Community/Group_Management/Berry_Investment_Group_BIG/Discussion.jnz?portlet=Forums&screen=PostView&screenType=change&id=13031261-5740-4204-84b7-36c45ad9b245,

  1503. Upvc Door Repairs Near Me Tools To Streamline Your Everyday Lifethe Only
    Upvc Door Repairs Near Me Trick That Should Be Used By
    Everyone Know upvc door repairs near me (Miles)

  1592. Hi there! This is my first comment here so I just wanted to give a quick shout out and say I
    really enjoy reading your posts. Can you suggest any other blogs/websites/forums that go
    over the same subjects? Thanks a lot!

  1653. Private ADHD Assessment Edinburgh Techniques To Simplify Your Daily
    Life Private ADHD Assessment Edinburgh Trick Every Person Should Be Able To private adhd assessment
    edinburgh (Valarie)

  1704. Pretty nice post. I just stumbled upon your weblog and wanted to say that I’ve truly enjoyed browsing your blog posts.
    After all I’ll be subscribing to your rss feed and I hope you write again soon!

  1768. Thanks for the good writeup. It actually was once a leisure account it. Look complicated to far delivered agreeable from you! By the way, how can we keep up a correspondence?

  1792. Kia Ceed Key Fob Replacement Tools To Ease Your Daily Lifethe One Kia Ceed Key Fob Replacement Trick That Should Be Used By Everyone Learn kia ceed key fob replacement (Jerald)

  1934. The Top Reasons For Peritoneal Mesothelioma
    Asbestos’s Biggest “Myths” About Peritoneal Mesothelioma Asbestos
    May Actually Be Right mesothelioma attorneys, Poppy,

  2008. Steve nash. Tuscaloosa. Millie bobby brown. Angel dust. Subtle. Stomach.

  2029. How To Get Diagnosed With ADHD In Adults Tools To Ease Your Daily Lifethe One
    How To Get Diagnosed With ADHD In Adults Trick That Everyone
    Should Know get diagnosed with adhd (Zelma)

  2124. Private ADHD Assessment Edinburgh Tools To Ease Your Daily Life Private ADHD Assessment Edinburgh Technique Every Person Needs To Be Able To private adhd assessment
    edinburgh (Kerstin)

  2224. Ghost Immobiliser Near Me Techniques To Simplify Your Everyday Lifethe Only
    Ghost Immobiliser Near Me Trick That Every Person Should Be
    Able To ghost immobiliser (Mozelle)

  2230. 15 Lessons Your Boss Wants You To Know About
    Private ADHD Assessment Swansea You’d Known About Private ADHD Assessment Swansea private adhd assessments (Annis)

  2284. Tall 50 50 Fridge Freezer Tips To Relax Your Daily
    Lifethe One Tall 50 50 Fridge Freezer Trick That Every Person Should Be Able To tall 50 50 fridge
    freezer (Vince)

  2309. В чем различие человек индивид личность.
    Тип майерс бриггс. Что такое сильная личность обществознание 6 класс примеры. Человек в отличие от представителей животного мира.
    2 личности в одном человеке как называется.
    Обонятельные ощущения относятся к.
    Мышление обществознание. Вау обои на телефон.

  2329. Профессиональный сервисный центр по ремонту бытовой техники с выездом на дом.
    Мы предлагаем: сервис центры бытовой техники москва
    Наши мастера оперативно устранят неисправности вашего устройства в сервисе или с выездом на дом!

  2468. The 3 Most Significant Disasters In Volvo Replacement Keys The Volvo Replacement Keys’s 3 Biggest
    Disasters In History replacement volvo xc90 key (Glory)

  2516. What Is The Best Folding Mobility Scooter To Buy Tools To Make Your Everyday Lifethe Only What Is The Best
    Folding Mobility Scooter To Buy Trick That Every Person Should Be
    Able To what is the best folding mobility scooter to buy; Dorthea,

  2611. Are You Responsible For The Treatment Of ADHD In Adults Budget?
    10 Amazing Ways To Spend Your Money how to treat depression and
    adhd; Karol,

  2637. Small Bunk Bed For Kids Tools To Make Your Daily Lifethe
    One Small Bunk Bed For Kids Trick Every Individual Should Know small
    bunk bed for kids (Jeremy)

  2665. L Shape Leather Settee Tools To Help You Manage Your Everyday Lifethe Only L
    Shape Leather Settee Trick That Everybody Should
    Learn l shape leather settee (Todd)

  2696. What’s The Most Common Fold Away Treadmill With Incline Debate Could Be As Black And White As You Might Think does treadmill incline burn more calories (Samuel)

  2755. Be On The Lookout For: How Treadmill Foldable Incline Is Taking Over And What You
    Can Do About It folding treadmill with incline,
    Gail,

  2812. How The 10 Worst Tilt And Turn Window Not Closing FAILS Of All
    Time Could Have Been Prevented tilt and turn window not
    closing properly (Eula)

  2835. ADHD Titration Waiting List Tools To Streamline Your Daily Life ADHD Titration Waiting List
    Trick Every Person Should Know adhd titration waiting list – Connie
    –

  2884. Chimineas For Sale Near Me Tips To Relax Your Daily Lifethe One Chimineas
    For Sale Near Me Trick That Every Person Should Know
    chimineas for sale near me, Reina,

  2885. The Worst Advice We’ve Seen About Pragmatic Authenticity Verification Pragmatic Authenticity Verification 프라그마틱 슬롯 하는법; Darin,

  2944. wonderful submit, very informative. I wonder why the other specialists of
    this sector do not understand this. You should proceed your writing.
    I’m confident, you have a huge readers’ base already!

  3042. Казино Вавада — это известное казино, предлагающее широкий
    выбор игр. Здесь представлены разнообразные слоты, а также игры с живыми дилерами.

    Особенность Вавада казино — это привлекательные акции и бонусы, включая приветственные бонусы.

  3055. “Ask Me Anything,” 10 Responses To Your Questions About
    Wall Mounted Electric Fireplaces log effect wall mounted electric fires; Larue,

  3075. Hiya! Quick question that’s completely off topic.

    Do you know how to make your site mobile friendly? My site looks weird when viewing from my
    apple iphone. I’m trying to find a template or plugin that might be able to resolve this problem.
    If you have any suggestions, please share. Thank you!
    buy lab-tested 2CB powder usa bulk, Order 2C-B powder with btc discreetly usa online, Affordable 2CB powder for sale, purchase legal 2CB powder usa online safety, buy pure 2CB powder legally USA

  3222. Fantastic beat ! I would like to apprentice whilst you amend your
    website, how could i subscribe for a blog web site?
    The account aided me a appropriate deal. I were tiny bit familiar of this your broadcast offered bright transparent
    concept

  3264. Dealing With ADHD Without Medication Tools To Streamline Your Everyday Lifethe Only Dealing With
    ADHD Without Medication Technique Every Person Needs To Be Able To
    dealing with adhd without medication (https://mental-health22737.thecomputerwiki.com/5001633/from_the_web_twenty_amazing_infographics_about_medication_for_adhd_and_anxiety)

  3377. Hello! I just wanted to ask if you ever have any issues with hackers?
    My last blog (wordpress) was hacked and I ended up losing several
    weeks of hard work due to no backup. Do you have any methods to prevent
    hackers?

  3381. Bandar Online Togel Tools To Ease Your Daily Lifethe One Bandar Online Togel Trick That Every Person Must Know bandar online togel, Ngan,

  3459. Realistic Doll For Sex Techniques To Simplify Your Daily Lifethe One Realistic Doll
    For Sex Trick That Should Be Used By Everyone
    Know realistic doll for sex; Polly,

  3485. This Is The One ADHD Private Diagnosis Glasgow Trick
    Every Person Should Be Aware Of private adhd assessment stoke on trent
    – Leon
    –